As she prepares for her wedding to David, Christy receives an unexpected visit from Dr. MacNeill. While out riding together, Dr. MacNeill surprises Christy with the news that he has returned to Cutter Gap for a reason: to ask her to marry him. When a sudden storm hits, Dr. MacNeill and Christy find themselves stranded in a nearby cabin. As the storm passes and Christy recovers, the right decision becomes as clear as the skies above. Unfortunately, her decision will leave one of her suitors brokenhearted.